NOTE: This forum is no longer active. This is an archive copy of the forum as it was on 10 March 2018.
IainB wrote:Now this is interesting. Probably not one to buy but reads the reviews!
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Classic-Whisky- ... 09&sr=1-13
IrishWhiskeyChaser wrote:IainB wrote:Now this is interesting. Probably not one to buy but reads the reviews!
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Classic-Whisky- ... 09&sr=1-13
Curious indeed ... very interesting that JM should voice his opinions and is obviously quite passionate (and angry) about what has happened to his book. Fair play ...
JohnM wrote:And to suggest his expertise on a world scale is limited to whisky is similarly modest. Only joking, Jim, if you're listening...
IrishWhiskeyChaser wrote:Poor auld JM is a victim of his own greatness
In all fairness he and Micheal Jackson were the pioneers of Malt when people did not know a talisker from a teachers. These 2 are possibly one of the major factors in all the Malt Mayhem in the world.
So much so that they along with the SMWS created a bit of a Malt Monster where alot of so called whisky aficinados now look down their noses at blends ... but that is their loss.
IainB wrote:Connemara Turf Mor (how do I add the sine fada again?)
IainB wrote:I'm getting through a bit more of the Dave Broom book - some quite new and interesting approaches - and I say that as someone with lots of whisky books. There's a lot of discussion about the impact of fermentation time, distillation cuts, reflux, worm condensers etc on the whisky - in most cases there's tasting notes on the new make spirit as well as at varying ages. Also interesting, in the context of the discussion in another topic on Connemara Turf Mor (how do I add the sine fada again?), he talks about how the amount of peat coming through to the end product can vary greatly depending on the fermantation time, which part of the cut is taken etc. So the higher or lower ppm isn't the only factor. Also interesting is that there are different elements to the phenols and that even at the same ppm there are different compounds from floor maltings that drum maltings that have an impact.
Interesting stuff, in a nerdy way!